Call us 
Prenup vs Postnup – Key Differences
Chapters
Chapter 6
Prenup vs Postnups – How Are They Different?
Prenuptial Agreement
A prenup is a legal agreement created before marriage, specifying how assets and liabilities will be divided in the event of a divorce.
It’s particularly useful in situations where one party brings significant financial assets or family wealth into the marriage.
As a family law solicitor, I’ve seen prenups become crucial in protecting business interests, property, or inheritances.
Prenups can also be used to prevent one spouse from acquiring a share of pre-owned assets that are meant for children from a previous marriage.
Key reasons for a prenup include:
- Unequal wealth between partners.
- Protecting assets from previous marriages.
- Ensuring family businesses are preserved.
Postnuptial Agreement
A postnup serves the same purpose as a prenup but is signed after the couple is already married.
Postnups can be particularly useful when financial circumstances change during the marriage, such as when one partner inherits assets or starts a successful business.
In many cases, couples who missed the opportunity to sign a prenup might opt for a postnup to address changes in their financial position.
Common reasons for a postnup include:
- Inheritance received during the marriage.
- Business ventures established after marriage.
- Significant changes in wealth, such as acquiring new assets or facing unexpected debts.
Key Difference
The primary distinction is timing.
Prenups are signed before marriage, while postnups are signed after.
Both agreements, however, offer similar legal protections and must meet the same legal requirements: fairness, full financial disclosure, and independent legal advice.
Courts generally view prenups more favourably, but postnups can be equally effective if created under the right circumstances.
How Much Do They Cost?
As solicitors, we understand that the costs associated with prenuptial and postnuptial agreements vary depending on the complexity of your finances.
It’s important to note that while these agreements are a worthwhile investment for protecting long-term financial interests, their price is influenced by several factors.
Prenuptial Agreement Costs
On average, the cost of drafting a prenup in the UK can range from £1,000 to £3,000.
The complexity of your assets—such as businesses, international properties, or trusts—can significantly increase the fee.
Additional negotiations between solicitors also add to the cost, especially if financial arrangements are highly complex.
Postnuptial Agreement Costs
A postnup is generally priced similarly to a prenup, ranging between £1,000 and £3,000.
However, postnups can be more expensive in cases where substantial assets were acquired during the marriage or if financial negotiations become contentious.
If your financial situation has changed significantly since the start of the marriage, the drafting of a postnup may require more detailed legal work and higher solicitor fees.
For both agreements, it’s crucial that each party obtains independent legal advice to ensure that the document is enforceable and protects both parties fairly. Skipping this step can result in the court disregarding the agreement.
Do Both Agreements Hold Up In Court?
One of the most common concerns I encounter from clients is whether a prenup or postnup will be enforceable in court.
While these agreements are not automatically legally binding in the UK, the courts have increasingly upheld them, provided they meet certain criteria.
Prenuptial Agreements
A prenup can carry significant weight in court if it is deemed fair. For a prenup to be enforceable, the following conditions must be met:
- Full Financial Disclosure: Both parties must fully disclose their financial situation, including assets, liabilities, and future income.
- Voluntary Agreement: The prenup must be entered into freely by both parties, without coercion or undue pressure.
- Independent Legal Advice: Each party should have received legal advice from separate solicitors before signing the agreement.
The landmark case Radmacher v Granatino set a precedent for the enforceability of prenuptial agreements.
The court ruled that a prenup should be upheld unless it would be unfair to do so, meaning that as long as the prenup was fair at the time of signing, it is likely to be respected by the court.
Postnuptial Agreements
Postnups are treated similarly to prenups by UK courts, but they may come under greater scrutiny if signed during a difficult period in the marriage.
Like prenups, postnups require full financial disclosure, voluntary agreement, and independent legal advice to be enforceable.
Courts may look at the timing of the postnup and whether one party felt pressured into signing it.
It is essential that both prenups and postnups are drafted carefully, with fairness at their core. If the agreement leaves one party in financial hardship, the court may disregard it.
When Should You Consider a Postnup Instead of a Prenup?
Postnuptial agreements are particularly useful when circumstances change during the marriage that wasn’t accounted for in a prenup—or if a prenup was never signed.
I frequently advise clients to consider a postnup after significant life events, as it helps to clarify financial arrangements moving forward and protect both parties in the event of a divorce.
Key life changes that might prompt the need for a postnup include:
- Inheritance: If one partner inherits assets during the marriage and wishes to ensure these remain separate from marital property.
- Business Ventures: Starting a business during the marriage can complicate financial arrangements, and a postnup can protect the business in the event of a divorce.
- Significant Changes in Wealth: A postnup allows both parties to update financial arrangements, especially when there is an increase or decrease in assets or liabilities.
Postnups are often used when a couple realises they need financial clarity during the marriage, which may not have been possible before they were married.
Disadvantages of a Postnuptial Agreement
While postnuptial agreements provide essential financial protection, there are potential disadvantages to be aware of, particularly in terms of court scrutiny and emotional sensitivity.
Potential Court Scrutiny
Postnups may face more scrutiny from the court than prenups, especially if the agreement was signed during a period of marital conflict.
The court could question whether the agreement was truly voluntary or if one party was pressured into signing.
This is especially relevant if the agreement seems to disproportionately benefit one party at the expense of the other.
Emotional Sensitivity
Negotiating a postnup can be emotionally challenging for couples, as it involves discussing the possibility of a future separation during the marriage.
This can introduce tension into the relationship, and some clients find that negotiating financial arrangements after marriage feels more invasive than doing so beforehand.
However, a well-drafted postnup can bring clarity and reassurance, making it easier to manage financial expectations.
Which Agreement is Right for You?
Both prenuptial and postnuptial agreements offer valuable protection for your financial future, but the choice between them depends on timing and your current circumstances.
Prenups are best suited for couples entering marriage with unequal assets or financial responsibilities, while postnups offer a way to adapt to changing financial circumstances during marriage.
As a family law solicitor, I always recommend seeking independent legal advice to ensure that your agreement is fair, enforceable, and tailored to your specific needs.
Regularly reviewing these agreements is also key to ensuring that they remain relevant and effective over time.